Every tooth was subject to longitudinal section of the midpulpal area. Gustafson created a method of dental age estimation, using six age related changes of teeth that occur after the eruption of the. Age estimation from teeth with critical analysis of gustafson s method article pdf available in journal of indian academy of forensic medicine 372. The statistical analysis was performed using medcalc software version 10. Dental age estimation using the demirjian method in malay children of. Modifications to the gustafson method of age estimation from teeth are. Different methods have been used for age estimation in different ranges of age. Visual, radiographic, chemical and histological techniques can be used for dental age estimation. A modified gustafson method of age estimation from teeth. We give a formula for what we believe to be the correct treatment of errors in such cases, but conclude by observing that there is an urgent need for a more rigorous study of the. Dental college, hospital and research institute, india priyanka nath.
Liversidge1 1queen mary university of london, institute of dentistry, london, e1 2ad, uk. Comparative study of age estimation using dentinal. Effectiveness of bang and ramms formulae in age assessment. Dental age assessment is one of the most reliable methods of chronological age estimation used for criminal, forensic and anthropologic purposes. Estimation of age by pulptooth area ratio using three computer.
Jan 07, 2014 age estimation from dentition the final step in triad of dental profiling, age estimation is an important subspecialty of forensic sciences. Further comments on the estimation of error associated with the gustafson dental age estimation method. Gustafson 14,30 first formulated observations of macrostructural changes in teeth into a workable system for adult age estimation. In the field of forensic medicine, odontology has got an important role in the determination of age as well as sex. Gustafsons method for age determination from teeth is based on the evaluation of ground sections of teeth. Such methods can not be used in adults where the structural changes are more subtle.
However, the issue of challenges faced in using these methods has been neglected. Summarized morphohistological methods of age estimation in adul. Forensic age estimation a unique approach bajpai, manas, k. The thickness of cementum was measured by using motic 2.
Assessment of age from the dentition is of great interest for the forensic odontologist in his work on identification of the unknown. Tooth development is widely used in determining age and state of maturity. These techniques are based on morphologically different stages of mineralization of all teeth willems 2001. Dental age estimation makes use of morphologic, radiographic, histologic, and biochemical methods to examine the age dependent changes in teeth. These changes were ranked on an arbitrary scale, being allotted 0, 1, 2 and 3 points according to the degree of change.
The most commonly used dental age estimation atlas techniques are those of schour and massler, moorrees and colleagues, gustafson and koch, and anderson et al. Gustafsons method for age determination from teetha. Estimating age from teeth is generally reliable as they are naturally preserved long after all the tissues and even bones have disintegrated. A study to determine the accuracy of gustafsons method of age estimation on adult teeth when applied to a sample of the population of the western cape. Results descriptive analysis of measurement indexes. Estimation of age by pulptooth area ratio using three computer aided software s, seema basoya, vinod vc, priyanka nath, ashwin d bhogte. Randomly selected teeth from 25 indians were examined by the gustafson method and by our own modification. Visual method is based on the sequence of eruption of the teeth and morphological changes that are caused due to function such as attrition, changes in. Estimation of age by pulptooth area ratio using three computer aided softwares seema basoya department of oral medicine and radiology, army college of dental sciences, india vinod vc department of oral medicine and radiology, s.
Age estimation from physiological changes of teeth. Comparative evaluation of two established age estimation. Pdf a comparative evaluation of gustafsons formula and new. Age estimation is an important factor in the identification of an individual in forensic cases. Two histological and radiological by image analysis software using single tooth. Two of these changes, transparency of radicular dentin and secondary dentin. The following dental parameters were studied in each case. The use of multiple age indicators offer superior results 2,3. Further, noninvasive studies used conventional dental radiographs of tooth to measure the pulptooth linear measurements and area ratios to estimate the age 10, 11. It was shown that our modified method resulted in more. Gustafson 1950 was the first to devise the microscopic method for age estimation based on the examination of regressive. Tooth formation is widely used to assess maturity and predict age. However, this statement has been contested nkhumeleni et al.
Further comments on the estimation of error associated with. Age estimation is one of the prime factors employed to establish identity. In this study image analysis software was implemented on the photographs of the. Dental age is of high importance in forensic and pediatric dentistry and also orthodontic treatment planning. Jan 05, 2010 age assessment in children and adolescents based on the stage of tooth development and eruption status of teeth is relatively accurate. Age estimation based on kvaals technique using digital.
Bhaskarb a, medical college, trivandrum and b, institute of medical sciences, osmania medical college, hvderabad india summary a study of 83 teeth using gustafson s method was made from 59 cases. A study to determine the accuracy of gustafsons method of. The gustafson technique is the most popular age estimation method that uses six variables, among which root dentin translucency is considered the best parameter for age estimation. Gustafson s method for age determination from teeth is based on the evaluation of ground sections of teeth. Forensic medicine mcq 21 most reliable criteria in. Age estimation in this study was done by two established radiological methods like tooth coronal index tci and kvaals method and two histological techniques kashyaps and koteswara modification of gustafsons method and secondary dentine method. A comparative evaluation of gustafsons formula and new. The actual age of the patient in each case was recorded. Schour and massler, ubelaker, and the london atlas s. The estimation of age performed on the basis of histological examination and evaluation of morphological changes in. Modification of the gustafson method of determination of age according to teeth on prehistorical and historical osteological material. Cameriere et al, also used kavval s method for age estimation using panoramic radiographs of maxillary canines in their preliminary study and offered a regression equation for age estimation.
A comparison of the accuracy of four age estimation. Among the traditional dental parameters used for estimating age, root dentin translucency is considered to be least affected by external stimuli and most suitable for the purpose. Age estimation from pulptooth area ratio using digital. Estimation of age by pulptooth area ratio using three. Assessing the accuracy of camerieres indianspecific formula.
Age estimation from physiological changes of teeth by gustafsons. Six ageassociated parameters are evaluated in the ground section and are compared to a regression curve of age versus the ageassociated changes. This study is based on modified gustafsons method to evaluate the physiological changes occurring in teeth during aging process and to estimate the age using multiple regression analysis. Bhagwat dayal sharma, post graduate institute of medical science, rohtak, haryana, india abstract. Pdf age estimation by gustafson method and its modifications. We offer another statistical analysis of gustafson s data and find that the errors calculated by maples and rice were also in error, being about a year too small. A software program that assists in metric estimation of sex, ancestry and statute techniques is known as. A total of 100 extracted teeth were used for this study. Mar 26, 2016 estimation of age at death using teeth 49 johanson g. Challenges in forensic odontology age estimation methods.
For age estimation the method according to gustafson was used. It uses methods which include the analysis of gustafson and johanson as well. The most common method in adults is using dental parameters used by gustafson in 1947. Apr 16, 2009 age assessment may be a crucial step in postmortem profiling leading to confirmative identification. A wide variety of age estimation methods are available for children, adolescents, and adults. The most reliable criteria in gustafson method of age estimation is. Age estimation from the physiological changes of teeth using. Age estimation by dentin translucency measurement using. Age estimation using canine pulp volumes in adults. Aug 30, 2019 in 1952, gustafson introduced an invasive method for age estimation based on six age related changes, including secondary dentine. Age estimation from teeth using gustafsons method a.
The most reliable criteria in gustafson method of age estimation is 1 secondary dentin deposition. They are designed to minimise the subjective nature of the scoring technique and to quantify the regressive changes in the enamel, dentine and cementum. Modifications to the gustafson method of age estimation from teeth are described. The gustafson s method is the most popular age estimation method being used since 1950. They reported that the actual age had a significant correlation with ar. The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of four radiographic age estimation methods. The most reliable criteria in gustafson method of age.
An accuracy of age estimation of radiographic methods balwant rai and s. Request pdf age estimation from physiological changes of teeth by gustafsons method age determination is crucial in medicolegal cases. Forensic medicine mcq 21 most reliable criteria in gustafson method of age estimation. Age estimation by gustafson method and its modifications. It uses six regressive changes in the tooth, namely, attrition, secondary dentin, gingival recession, cemental apposition, root resorption, and root transparency. Estimation of age by secondary dentin deposition, root translucency, and. The gustafsons method is the most popular age estimation method being used since 1950. Reviews in age estimation methods using teeth as a tool indicator have been exhausted and are widely available in the literature. Gustafson 4 was the first in formulating a method to age estimation, based on six characteristic s of the dental structure. Johanson proposed amendments in the gustafsons method. They are designed to minimise the subjective nature of the scoring technique and to quantify the regres sive changes in the enamel, dentine and cementurn.
Dental pulp undergoes regression in size with increasing age due to secondary dentin deposition and can be used as a parameter of age estimation even beyond 25 years of age. Comparison between males and females showed nonsignificant results and left side of the opg showed superior results when compared with the right side for age estimation. The gustafson technique is the most popular age estimation test being used since 1950. Age estimation using three established methods a study on indian. Age estimation from teeth using gustafsons method a study. He presented his models based on microscopic and macroscopic features of teeth in 1950. Adult age determination from teeth was carried out using three methods, namely, johanson method, methods of kashyap and koteswar rao and the average stage of attrition method asa. Gustafson was the first worker to use root resorption and root transparency for age estimation in a systematic manner. Using this variable, bang and ramm in 1970 developed an elaborate method and formulae for predicting age in.
He used six retrogressive changes in teeth, namely attrition, secondary dentin deposition, periodontal status, root transparency, cementum apposition, and root resorption. Gustafson 1950 1 devised a multivariate method of age estimation using six of these measures of histological change. Estimation of age by secondary dentin deposition, root. Six age associated parameters are evaluated in the ground section and are compared to a regression curve of age versus the age associated changes. Morphology and volume of maxillary canine pulp cavity for. Acharya described a new and comparatively simple method for capturing and quantifying refined measurements of dentinal translucency on sectioned teeth using commercially available hardware and software.
487 682 736 521 170 1342 1207 1017 1042 929 1136 802 952 24 1020 376 753 428 969 905 413 1122 962 631 1130 9 1195 1433 1307 662 1316 91 1156 829 1137 1216 342 1229 575 757 1051